What to do when a coaching client has strong beliefs that limit their thinking
Everyone has some beliefs that they hold onto, even when logic suggests that this is irrational. For the most part, these are harmless and are simply part of our identity. For example, the theories of reflexology and homeopathy have both been thoroughly debunked as nonsense. However, unless the practitioner puts the client in danger by steering them away from other, evidence-based treatments, they do no harm and the relationship with the practitioner may have therapeutic benefits.
Irrational beliefs come in many forms. It is the intensity, with which people hold on to them, that distinguishes the beneficial and “normal” from the harmful. So, for example, religious belief provides people with life purpose and meaning; but religious fundamentalism leads to multiple damaging outcomes. The belief that politicians work to hidden agendas might be regarded as a justifiable precautionary perspective, but extreme conspiracy theories lead to violence such as that demonstrated by Trump supporters storming the Capitol.
When strong, irrational beliefs become dysfunctional or damaging to a client or to others, it raises ethical issues for coaches working with them. Is it our responsibility to challenge their beliefs? Is it even appropriate to do so? What irrational beliefs might we bringing? Are our perceptions of reality genuinely more valid than theirs?
A helpful concept here is consequence of beliefs. Rather than challenge a belief, we accept that it is genuinely held and explore the questions, such as:
- What does this belief enable you to do and what does it prevent you doing? (How does it empower and disempower you?)
- What does it enable and prevent others from doing? (How does it enable or prevent others being their best?)
- How does it affect how you relate to others?
- How does it affect how others relate to you?
The power of this approach is that it avoids the instinctive fight/flight response that arises whenever someone feels their beliefs are assailed. It also helps them step out of missionary mode (where they feel bound to convert you) and to begin to acknowledge other perspectives, even if they are not yet ready to accept or endorse them. Helping them to listen to themselves is a starting point for listening to others.
It’s also valuable to use the opportunity to question our own assumptions and, in particular, the assumption that our roles as coaches is to “help the client see reason”. An alternative assumption is that our role is to support the client in becoming curious about other perspectives than their own – and that changes in their beliefs are their responsibility, not ours.
Epiphanies do happen, but they are rare compared with a person’s gradual recognition that an existing belief set isn’t working for them. A coaching conversation is typically only a small step in that long journey.
© David Clutterbuck 2023
Related Content
-
It’s National Mentoring Day again
27th October 2026 I’m pleased to announce that I h...
-
How to get the best out of your training and development budget.
“Training and development is like advertising. Nob...
-
Whatever happened to compassion, courage, curiosity and connection?
Several years ago, I trawled through a great mass ...
-
The role of AI in ethical coaching and mentoring
A recent paper in Philosophy Now explores the issu...
-
Mentor-coach or supervisor?
There has been a lot of confusion over the years.....
-
The other side of unconditional positive regard
Coaches can support executives in recognising what...
-
There is no such thing as neurotypical
Here’s yet another new word – Phantomolog – ...
-
Readiness for change: The comfort-curiosity matrix
It’s common for coaches and mentors to feel frustr...
-
A simple tool for emotional reflection
It’s good practice for coaches and mentors to spen...
-
How to overcome executive stress – the secret lies in reconnection
Coaches can support executives in recognising what...
-
Professional coach or professional mentor?
The work of the Coach Maturity Research Group demo...
-
The addictive power of AI
One of the results of this is that the more we use...
-
Making the team coaching pitch: a checklist
This checklist might be helpful in ensuring your p...
-
The perils of the passive coachee
The word spiritual keeps cropping up in relational...
-
Supporting well-being: The importance of rest
The word spiritual keeps cropping up in relational...
-
What does it mean to be spiritual?
The word spiritual keeps cropping up in relational...
-
Corporate B.S versus critical thinking
B.S receptivity refers to a person's tendency to e...
-
Two new books to stimulate innovative thinking
I make it a rule to challenge at least one deeply ...
-
Should a toxic work environment be classified as a breach of industrial safety requirements?
If an employer fails to ensure a workplace or work...
-
The subtle art of miscommunication
I was recently introduced to the work of Finnish r...
-
Coaching versus mentoring: an outcomes perspective
Clarifying the differences between coaching and me...
-
Climate Coaching Action Day – March 5th
What can you, as a coach, do for the planet......
-
How team narratives shape team behaviour
Our understanding of behaviour in teams has been i...
-
Changing the debate on neurodivergence
I was pointed to a fascinating book at an EMCC web...
-
Challenging times for Human Resources
I was pointed to a fascinating book at an EMCC web...
-
We’re all neurodiverse
I was pointed to a fascinating book at an EMCC web...
-
Is AI creating two-tier coaching?
Coach-bots are becoming more and more sophisticate...
-
12 habits of a Toxic Mentor
The following are all examples of behaviours by me...
-
Work-life balance and employee well-being are systems issues
The potential is high for hybrid working to enable...
-
The most common mistakes in mentoring programmes
Over four decades, I have encountered thousands of...
-
Team coaching in pairs: Research from CCMI
The aim of this research was to throw light on......
-
The downsides of excessive positivity
One of the characteristics of organisations, which...
-
Why mentoring and coaching programmes need a dedicated manager
Creating a coaching and mentoring culture isn’t ea...
-
Your work-life balance
Your work-life balance 20 questions....
-
A systems perspective on coaching culture
One of the characteristics of organisations, which...
-
10 good reasons for having a coaching culture
Coaching culture is one of those concepts that eve...
-
Getting to the roots of diversity and inclusion
Over the decades, I have developed dozens of model...
-
How to help someone reflect on their future career: using the Ikegai questions
The Japanese concept of Ikegai is based around fou...
-
What did you learn about yourself this week?
Building the habit of reflection isn’t easy. Yet,...
-
What do executives think are the benefits of team coaching?
Manfred Kets de Vries, at INSEAD, the French busin...
-
The dangers of relying on an AI to write an article
AIs like Gemini or ChatGPT can be very helpful in ...
-
The potential matrix
In order to take up a challenge, we need agency (a...
-
Psychedelic coaching
Board directors have immense responsibility – the ...
-
Tomorrow’s Board: Why every director needs the skills of coaching and mentoring
Board directors have immense responsibility – the ...
-
How to make new habits stick
“Stacking” is a term that refers to linking a habi...
-
A simple approach to ethical dilemmas
The Defiance Compass poses three powerful question...
-
How teams fall foul of “illusory truths”
Illusory truth theory describes the phenomenon, by...
-
What does it mean to be present as a coach or mentor?
Presence is one of those words that gets used and ...
-
Enter the Otrovert
I once went through a battery of psychometric test...
-
The protégé effect: How mentors learn from mentoring
The protégé effect: How mentors learn from mentori...
-
An executive’s last 24 months in role before retirement – how to maximise the transfer of wisdom
Whenever a valued executive retires after many yea...
-
Core Qualities
Daniel Ofman’s Core Qualities model seeks to expla...
-
Feedback loops in Team systems
Feedback loops are an intrinsic part of all but th...
-
Future Story
Both individuals and teams often find it hard to f...
-
How Anyone Can Become More Trustworthy and Create Psychological Safety
Article by Deiric McCann, Genos Trustworthiness of...
-
From Teaming to Steaming
When a team is all aligned and coherent, we talk.....
-
Stages of Development of a Coaching Culture
David Meggison & I explored the concept of org...
-
Getting to know a coachee: Clutterbuck’s 13 questions
Psychometrics and other forms of diagnostic, such ...
-
What are we going to do with HR Banalytics?
We hear more and more about the virtues of HR......
-
Self-reflection versus self-rumination
Introspection – being able to look in at ourselves...
-
Reflections of HRDs internationally
If I knew then what I know now…Reflections of HRDs...
-
What happens when you can’t keep your thoughts to yourself?
The new technologies of brain-AI interfaces have p...
-
Team energy questions
The following questions aim to help teams and team...
-
If I knew then what I know now… what aspiring HR Directors need to know
The transition from senior HR professional to a Bo...
-
Team Personality
This technique aims to generate shared perceptions...
-
Why is it so difficult to create a coaching culture?
The concept of a coaching culture has been a serio...
-
Where is your organisation on the route to a coaching culture?
We know it’s difficult — for many reasons — but kn...
-
What makes a cost-effective coaching and mentoring strategy?
While most large employers at least pay lip servic...
-
Helping the team gain a more strategic perspective
Strategic thinking is both an art and a skill. It ...
-
The Corporate Biome
One of the greatest revelations of 21st Century sc...
-
How to be positively cynical
At first thought, “positively cynical” seems like ...
-
What’s your system as a coach?
Although it doesn’t figure highly in some competen...
-
Coach the system, not the client
Mature coaches coach very differently to their les...
-
AI versus human: the issue of memory
Yet another perspective on the differences between...
-
Could your next career be Professional Mentor?
As executives in organisations come up to retireme...
-
Beyond Team Coaching: Staying ahead of the game
Burnout is a phenomenon we usually associate with ...
-
What’s the point of mentor accreditation?
Burnout is a phenomenon we usually associate with ...
-
Why mature coaches are increasingly moving towards being professional mentors
Burnout is a phenomenon we usually associate with ...
-
Planning for team resilience
Burnout is a phenomenon we usually associate with ...
-
The diversity of neurodiversity
The instinct to categorise and classify is one of ...
-
Coaching the Board: A challenge for executive coaches
There’s no universal model of a board – it varies ...
-
Becomingness: a critical element of coaching and mentoring
It’s called status inflation and it starts when ki...
-
You’re an executive coach. Really?
It’s called status inflation and it starts when ki...
-
Time for a radical rethink of middle management?
Is middle management as we know it obsolete? There...
-
International Women’s Day 2025
A few days ago, a newspaper item caught my eye.......
-
Psychological safety and neurodivergence
The relationship between performance at work and p...
-
Making hybrid working work
One of the first things we learned when a company....
-
Making change happen
This simple formula helps someone plan how to brin...
-
The leader as lonely dragon: a parable of imposter syndrome
Once there was a dragon king, who lived in a......
-
What makes genius teams tick?
Every now and then, we meet teams that are extraor...
-
The expectation exchange
Friction within teams or between individuals often...
-
Four keys to better conversations online
A useful summary of research into successful onlin...
-
Tangles – a new metaphor for coaching harmonics
Whether it be a computer cable, a garden hose or.....
-
My AI doesn’t understand me Part 2 (A fictional supervision conversation from the not-too-distant future)
I’ve written a lot in recent years about the coach...
-
Systemic thinking for coaches
Systemic awareness is a basic requirement of an ef...
-
What I’m reading this summer break (August 2024)
Apart from a stack of new science fiction, which i...
-
How organisational leaders can continue to add value after retirement
As business leaders enter their late 50s and 60s, ...
-
The expanding complexity of coaching
The scope of coaching – in terms of the scale......
-
Who is in control of how you spend your time?
One of the key aspects of a sense of work-life......
-
Working with highly sensitive people
The more we understand and appreciate the value of...
-
The Power of Emotionally Intelligent Presence
How the Way You ‘Show Up’ Shape Your Influence and...
-
Developing ‘Practical Self-Awareness’
The Key to Intentional Influence and Impact - arti...
-
Another step into unreality
One of the anchors of people’s sense of security i...
-
ICF? EMCC? What’s the difference?
Once upon a time (not so long ago, really) there.....
-
PERILL Team Diagnostic
Just Launched - Visit the PERILL Website Prof Davi...
-
Coaching Executives (article by Craig McKenzie)
Coaching executives is a large part of the Transce...
-
If it’s worth doing, it’s worth doing differently
Today is Opposite Day (25th January, 2024) The boo...
-
Could AI replace the Board?
A couple of decades ago, when I was advising the.....
-
Belonginess surveys – how to get under the surface of people’s lived experience at work
When someone feels they belong in an environment, ...
-
The theme for this year’s International Women’s Day is inclusion…
The struggle for gender equality has been the pion...
-
Stages of team development
A frequent comment from coaches on our team coachi...
-
Choosing a team coaching co-coach
While it’s not essential always essential to have ...
-
Pain in the system
Whether working with an individual or a team, coac...
-
Learning from the learning disadvantaged
When I reflect on what I am grateful for, high......
-
Tied up in knots? Does knitting therapy bind the coach-client relationship?
When I first heard of coaching sessions, where bot...
-
The Seven Layers of Mentoring
Dialogue in mentoring, and in related disciplines ...
-
The disconnected executive
Somewhere in my files is a note on a piece......
-
Introducing the Workaholiday
Creating a personal balance between the work-relat...
-
Putting the value into teamwork: the role of Team Coaching
One of the first things I often ask when getting.....
-
Time to shift focus from individuals and linear thinking to teams and systems thinking
A survey I conducted three years ago found that 80...
-
How coaches and mentors can help clients on the autistic spectrum be authentic
Imagine coming to work each day and putting on an....
-
What do executive coaches and their clients talk about?
A study from Oxford Brookes University found 40 to...
-
Supervision as coach pair
Two coaches working together with a client team ne...
-
Grow up? I think I’ll pass
It’s said that “growing old is compulsory; growing...
-
How much of what you do each day at work is truly useful?
It’s one of those showstopper questions that peopl...
-
How to cultivate “belongingness” in teams
When someone feels they belong in an environment, ...
-
Where does happiness sit on the coaching client’s agenda?
The remarkable thing about coaching clients puttin...
-
Three levels of purpose
One of the reasons teams struggle to define their ...
-
How much quality time does your team spend together?
When domestic couples are too busy to spend qualit...
-
What’s in a gesture?
Cultures differ in how much people instinctively g...
-
Why every leader needs their own manifesto
What do you stand for? If you were asked this......
-
Starting to create psychological safety
One of the everyday challenges for team coaches is...
-
Educating the Board: A key role for HR
A recent study by PWC and The Conference Board rev...
-
How coaching and mentoring are evolving in China and India
After several years absence from Hong Kong in the ...
-
Would you choose YOU as your best friend?
As a question to stimulate reflection, this can be...
-
Mentorship in finance: A great leveller?
Well-designed and managed mentoring initiatives ca...
-
Another strong reason for rooting out toxic bosses
The immediate impact of toxic bosses on their team...
-
Why the great resignation is a good thing
Across America last year almost 20 million people ...
-
Traditional, reverse and reciprocal mentoring – a continuing evolution
Formal mentoring programmes have been around since...
-
How fast is coaching changing?
There’s no doubt that the world of coaching is cha...
-
How to help clients reset and recover
Studies from the University of Groningen in the Ne...
-
Coach development plan – a key to continuous Professional Development
Professional coaches and mentors are in the busine...
-
What does it take to make the transition from 1-2-1 coach to team coach?
Team coaching is the fastest growing area of coach...
-
Trust recovery in the team
Once trust is broken in a team, it is hard......