Here are some cases of team situations.
The table below illustrates how an outsider might see the teams’ issues from linear, systems or complex, adaptive systems perspectives.
The tired team
“If I’m honest”, says the team leader Flavian, “I’d say that pretty much the whole team demonstrates the Peter Principle. They have been promoted to the point of their incompetence. Technically, they are all very competent. But as managers and leaders… I am constantly asking them why they are spending time doing tasks that their direct reports could do, but that’s their comfort zone. They don’t like strategy work and frankly, they are out of their depth when they try. I did bring in a younger, more visionary member to the team, but she quit after a few months saying she was tired of not getting through to them.”
“It doesn’t help that their job roles don’t involve a lot of task interdependence – they and their own teams don’t need to reference anyone else but me. I am under a lot of pressure from my Exco colleagues and the CEO to “fix” them. Firing them all and starting again would be too disruptive and we are not that kind of company. How can you help?”
The merged team
Overall, the merger of the two real estate businesses has gone surprisingly well. A year after the merger, however, the IT team is struggling to come together. There is no obvious conflict, but at lunchtimes, the members who came from the smaller merger partner – all of them under 25 – sit separately from the team from the larger partner, who are from a slightly older generation. A manifestation of this divide is the frequency of rework that has to be done as a result of miscommunication and misunderstandings. These in turn cause delays and the team leader is under pressure from above to get work back on track before the next phase of systems integration.
The dispirited team
A tobacco company’s subsidiary in South America is trying to reinvent itself. The global company sees great opportunity in moving from an industry that kills people to one that cures them. The emphasis of all research and investment is moving into using vaping technology to deliver metered doses of medicines. But the bulk of income still comes from the core cigarette business, which is under pressure to deliver higher profits to finance the new strategy. The production team for cigarettes is despondent. They no longer feel valued – all the recognition is going to people in the new ventures – and they have missed targets for four successive quarters. “No-one has any time for us now,” says the team leader. The sponsor – a regional director – asks you what you could do to re-motivate the team and emphasises that they will not have any extra resources. He explains: “It must be hard having been the kingpin in the organisation, and now to be just a cash cow. But that’s the reality and they have to learn to live with it.”
The too busy team
Doh! is a quirky, fast-growing artisan bakers, supplying upmarket restaurants and eateries. From a garage start-up, it now has more than 200 staff baking and delivering bread. It is negotiating with a national supermarket chain to supply 100 stores in a pilot that could lead to massive expansion. Just four years old as a business, it lacks a lot of processes that would be expected in a more mature company. Its HR team has expanded in the past 12 months from one HR manager and an assistant to a team of eight. All of them are “run off their feet” trying both to make up for the lack of process before and to prepare the company for the future expansion. At team meetings there is usually at least one person absent because they are dealing with a crisis. Says the team leader: “At our last meeting, one of the team said to another: ‘I didn’t know you had kids!”. When we got to talking, we realised that we hardly know each other at all. As an HR function, we are supposed to promote human values in the business, but we aren’t setting a good example.”
The Olympic team
Whenever a country hosts the Olympic Games, it has to create an organisation to project manage the event. The headcount swells to hundreds or thousands until the Games are over and everyone goes home – then shrinks to a much smaller rump, whose task is to manage the aftermath. This may include repurposing sports venues, or in some cases demolishing them, finding new uses for accommodation blocks and so on. One of the big challenges is keeping people engaged when they know they have soon to look for a new job. How do we stay as a team, when one by one we are leaving?
© David Clutterbuck, 2020